Insured and Non-insured Depressed Outpatients: How Do They Compare?
Ira M. Lesser MDAndrew F. Leuchter MD
Madhukar H. Trivedi MD
Lori L. Davis MD
Stephen R. Wisniewski PhD
G.K. Balasubramani PhD
Maurizio Fava MD
A. John Rush MD
pages: 73 - 82
- DOI: 10.1080/10401230701334671
- Version of record first published: 27Apr2007
Abstract:
Background. The purpose of this study was to examine associations between clinical and demographic characteristics of depressed patients and source of payment for care. We attempted to confirm and extend findings from a previous study regarding the first 1500 participants enrolled in the Sequenced Treatment Alternatives to Relieve Depression (STAR*D) study with 2541 participants enrolled in later stages of the trial.
Methods. Demographic, clinical, and presenting symptom features were compared among participants with public, private or no insurance.
Results. Compared to those having private or no insurance, participants with public insurance were older; more likely to be women, Hispanic, widowed or divorced, unemployed, and less educated; were more frequently seen in primary care; had greater medical comorbidity and functional impairment, and a later age of depression onset. The publicly insured also had a longer current episode, but fewer episodes over their lifetime. Both the publicly insured and the uninsured had poorer life satisfaction compared to those with private insurance. Participants without insurance were intermediate between those with public and private insurance regarding several demographic characteristics and measures of severity.
Conclusions. Depressed outpatients with public insurance demonstrated greater functional impairment, though they did not have a more severe depression per se. Participants without insurance seemed to be a heterogeneous group with a presentation intermediate between those with public and private insurance. Those with public insurance were overrepresented in primary care clinics; therefore, clinicians in these settings need to be particularly vigilant in recognizing depression and offering appropriate treatments.